Author | Lodder, Arno R. author |
---|---|
Title | DiaLaw [electronic resource] : On Legal Justification and Dialogical Models of Argumentation / by Arno R. Lodder |
Imprint | Dordrecht : Springer Netherlands : Imprint: Springer, 1999 |
Connect to | http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-94-011-3957-1 |
Descript | XII, 198 p. online resource |
1 Introduction -- 1. Artificial Intelligence and Law -- 2. Legal justification -- 3. Outline of the book -- 2 From law to DiaLaw Why legal justification should be modeled dialogically -- 1. The product and the process of justification -- 2. Justification as a product -- 3. The defeasible nature of legal justification -- 4. The open nature of law -- 5. The Mรผnchhausen Trilemma -- 6. Justification as a process: a dialogical model -- 7. Dealing with defeasibility, open nature, and the Mรผnchhausen Trilemma in a dialogical model -- 8. Justification of dialog rules and altering protocols -- 9. How pure is the procedure of legal justification? -- 10. Conclusion -- 3 DiaLaw Framework and general rules -- 1. Justification in DiaLaw -- 2. Basic concepts of DiaLaw -- 3. DiaLawโs dialogical framework -- 4. General rules for communication -- 5. Towards legal justification -- 4 DiaLaw Special rules for communication -- 1. Special language elements -- 2. Special rules for communication - legal tools and forced commitment -- 3. Concluding remarks -- 5 DiaLaw in action -- 1. The Tyrell case -- 2. The Chabot case -- 3. Concluding remarks -- 6 Dialogical models of argumentation -- 1. The purpose of models -- 2. A short sample dialog -- 3. Mackenzieโs DC and Hamblinโs H -- 4. Rescherโs Dialectics and the formal elaboration by Brewka -- 5. Gordonโs Pleadings Game -- 6. Survey of moves and commitment -- 7. Other related research -- 8. Conclusion -- 7 What is an argument? Properties of procedural models of argumentation -- 1. Argumentation: two perspectives -- 2. Argumentation: two types -- 3. Towards combining the approaches -- 4. DiaLaw: rational and dia-rational argumentation -- 5. Procedural and structural arguments -- 6. Layers in models of legal argumentation -- 7. Conclusion -- 8 In conclusion -- 1. On legal justification -- 2. The answers -- 3. The future: towards natural dialog models -- 4. Closing remarks -- Appendix- Prolog code of DiaLaw -- References -- Index of names -- Index of subjects