Page 310 - clra62_0019-(GIPE)
P. 310

302      .  ECONOMIC INQUIRIES  AND  STUDIES
                  undoubtedly  prodigious.  The  loss  and  suffering  en-
                  tailed  were  enormous,  and  people  would  have  bcren
                   much  better off if they had  had  no  war  to  pay for.
                  What I  have endeavoured  to  show, however, isCthat
                  the question of loss and suffering is one thing, and the
                  question of waste or diminution of capital quite another
                  thing.
                     Having  stated this  conclu~ion, I  desire  to  add one
                  or  two  practical  comments.  I  have  rather  avoided
                  comment in the course of the paper, believing it to be
                  essential  to  arrive  at  the  facts,  whatever  the  com-
                  mentary may be,  but comment itself may be useful in
                  order to  avoid  misapprehension.  It ought  not  to  be
                  inferred  from  anything  that  has  been  said  that  the
                  question  of large  military preparations is  a matter of
                  indifference to any country, but  the  inference  may be
                  drawn  all  the  same,  however  erroneously,  from  an
                  argument  intended  to  cut  down  some  of  the  usual
                  statements  on  the  subject  and  to  show that some  of
                  the alleged mischiefs  of these  armaments  do  not,  in
                  fact,  exist.  It may be  useful,  therefore, to  state some
                  of the practical lessons of the facts,  as ascertained.
                     I  fear, then, we must conclude that there is no prac-
                  tical advantage  in .arguing against  the continuance of
                  bloated armaments  by  the  great  military  powers,  or
                  against the necessity of corresponding armaments  by
                  more  peaceful  powers  like  England.  The  military
                  powers  have  no  idea  on  the  subject  but that ·of de-
                  veloping their military strength to the utmost practical
                  limit, and to show that the margin of their resources is
                  yet  unexhausted  is  to  show  that  they  may  continue
                  the game.  I t would be a different matter if the nations
                  they represent  were exhausting  their  capital,  so  that
                  their taxpaying  power was  diminishing;  but  the  con-
                  trary is  the  case.  The Governments  are  quite  aware
                  that their subjects  would  have  more to spend if taxa-
                  tion were to be diminished, but they consider expendi-
                  ture  on  armaments  necessary  to  the  State  and,  for
   305   306   307   308   309   310   311   312   313   314   315